Mulrow,
Cynthia D.Helping an obese patient make informed choices. (Clinical
Review) British Medical Journal v317, n7153 (July 25, 1998): 266 (2
pages).Copyright 1998 British Medical Association (U.K.)
Not
long ago, a patient, whom I will call Mrs. Bariatrico, asked me to prescribe
a diet pill for her. Mrs.
Bariatrico is a middle class woman aged 48 years. She is 1.6m tall and
weighs 77.2 kg. Her body mass index is 30.2 and her waist to hip ratio
is 1.0 Mrs. Bariatrico is healthy and does not smoke. She told me she
plans to enroll in a commercial diet programme and believes her ability
to change her lifestyle is good? Her main concern is cosmetic--she values
"looking good" and considers weight loss an important outcome.
As
her primary care provider, I had several concerns. I knew the health
insurance system that serves Mrs. Bariatrico has no formal weight loss
programmes, and the cost of appetite suppressing drugs in not reimbursed.
I had some doubts about my own ability to manage obesity and asked the
following questions:
Work Janis A.. Exercise for the overweight
patient.Physician and Sportsmedicine v18, n7 (July, 1990):
113 (2 pages).
Exercise
alone is not enough to achieve weight loss for an obese patient. The
overweight patient must exercise to keep off the pounds lost through
dieting. Exercise programs must involve a minimum of 20 to 30 minutes
maintained at a conversational level (i.e. being able to maintain
a conversation during exercise) and patients should exercise lasting
one hour per session and performed three to fives times a week is
recommended to burn calories and avoid injuries.
Exercise performed on a regular basis is as important as the duration
and therefore walking three times a week or every day is highly recommended,
since it is safe and can be performed anywhere. There is reduced risk
of trauma and overuse injuries form swimming; however, patients may
be self-conscious in a swimsuit and this type of exercise may not
be a good first choice.
Cross
country ski machines, stationary bicycles, and rowing machines may
be used, and in fact, any form of activity is good so long as it is
safe for the patient. Exercise for overweigh patients should involve
total body motion of the use of large muscle groups. It is important
to remember that the dropout rate from all exercise programs is high;
statistics show that only 20 percent of those that start an exercise
program continue it for one year. Exercise must become part of a patient's
life and it may be a social event if the patient joins a gym or exercises
with a friend. Patients should be encouraged to follow a routine in
a health club before purchasing equipment and attempting to exercise
at home. Physicians should motivate patients in order to achieve the
benefits of exercise. The patient and the physician should plan a
program that is realistic and includes activities that the patient
will enjoy in order to achieve long lasting results. Physicians should
communicate to the patient both the benefits of exercise and the health
risks of not exercising.Some obese patients may have multiple musculoskeletal
problems, and before initiating an exercise program it would be useful
to encourage patients to simply become more active. Patients should
avoid the use of television remote controls, they should walk instead
of driving a car, and should climb stairs instead of using an elevator.
Patients with health problems such as hypertension or diabetes, or
those on very low caloric diets may require special considerations.
Exercise is an important component of maintaining weight loss and
should be a positive lifestyle change. (Consumer Summary produced
by Reliance Medical Information, Inc.) 7.
RETURN
TO MAIN LISTING